Clash of Lords 2 Today: 0    Total Posts: 1444

Moderator: Dragoneyr

Total:#10

Create Thread

[Chat (WP)] guild clash just killed my guild!!!!

[Copy link] 9/1153

#1
Posted on 12/31/15 2:54:30 PM | Show thread starter's posts only

My guild has had the worst luck on guild clash. Every week its one or two top 5 guilds, and they kill by 25-30 k. How is this fun losing every week, can't see my guild lasting the weekend because this is 10 week we lost in a row. This week we are fighting 4th and 5th place guild we are 8th the only one team we can beat is the 11th place guild and we beat them by 15-20k. Things need to change fast or game will die, people need to win once and while.

Signature
#2
Posted on 12/31/15 9:15:39 PM | Show thread starter's posts only

There is nothing wrong with this. If there are 4 guilds, it's normal that 1 or 2 will be stronger than yours, and 1 or 2 guild weaker than yours. If your guild is rank 8, it's very normal to have 1-2 guild at top 5.

Signature
#3
Posted on 12/31/15 9:27:06 PM | Show thread starter's posts only

This is a theme and struggle.  I and every other person on planet have been trying to get IGG to use  a ranking system involved instead of top 5 heroes.
Hell I had 6 guys who didnt sign up  but ranked high  because of holidays/travel and we got 50ked, the guild that did that to us got the same abuse the next week but we won.. The disparities are painful.

Signature
IGG ID: 194 546 514
My Databases - http://col2.forum.igg.com/topic?ctid=191116&t=1432354874
My Facebook Guild group https://www.facebook.com/groups/ArgonautsGuild/
My Guild
#4
Posted on 1/1/16 3:16:55 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

Ok. Here is solution
Join our guild. Although I cannt guarentee 1st place but 2nd for sure. We would be glad to see lord lok you our guild.
Indian.

Signature
#5
Posted on 1/1/16 9:30:18 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

See that above post is the epicenter of the issue. Screw guilds that lose not because of effort but because of mentality that a loss means a weak guild. Sure for some in top echelon it maybe services for hire but please don't let bad matchups make you quit a good guild with good ppl, every week its the same thing.
If I was more industrious my guild may be much higher, I'm very happy with us being good but I don't want the 8 hours a day I spend on it to become 14.
IGG is certainly doing its best to break us a part.

Signature
IGG ID: 194 546 514
My Databases - http://col2.forum.igg.com/topic?ctid=191116&t=1432354874
My Facebook Guild group https://www.facebook.com/groups/ArgonautsGuild/
My Guild
#6
Posted on 1/2/16 1:12:16 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

We have the same problem we are a 20 to 25 rank guild. But every week we are matced with one or two top 5 guild. IGG needs to fix this as it is hard to keep a guild together when we always loose! And when you do not have HUGE money spenders in your guild it is hard to compete with the top 5 Guilds

Signature
AOG
#7
Posted on 1/2/16 6:17:09 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

remove the top 5 players from your guild

Signature
#8
Posted on 1/2/16 8:42:17 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

But the top 5 in actual strength (pure hero wise) isnt even the top 5 according to the GC matchup system. And that match up system also leaves base differences out of the picture.
We have some members who are f2p causing them to have high aid lvls of bad heroes (BB, GP) because easy to get. Their main heroes are way lower and not well evolved. But according the the GC system they are equal in strength of people with all 160 new heroes and max evolution for their lvl.
Here is the biggest flaw in the GC system.
Everybody drops trophies so I think the top 5 heroes of each guildmember is the biggest factor in deciding the matchups. As long as the systems keeps thinking a lvl 180 BB is same as a 180 Am Pisces, GC matchup will never be fair.

Signature
#9
Posted on 1/2/16 10:56:07 PM | Show thread starter's posts only

There is something else going on, I have a 80  listed at the top of list but a 121 @ third. There is no way that 80 could be more powerful as the 121 has almost all 180+ aids and more Scorpio and Sagittarius.

I am beginning to believe that power is also placed on a scale with power to level ratio. So a 80 with 1 180  SM aid  and  1 Libra on Ambrosia is going to be ranked higher than a 120 if they had the same exact heroes.
If not then there is something else just as insidious going on to make a lower level ranked higher.

Old school players who did level up what they had prior to all of the new heroes are still relevant.  The merc increase and potential there even if the they only use a few of the new heroes as generally it comes down to that and aid and skill in GC.
That's based on potential, some people might not have pieces to a puzzle for synergy or their design is BR and or GC related and lacks GC related needs.

No matter what the current system stinks and we are in line for back to back week @ #1  even though top personal is always changing. We are currently winning by a 7-20k margin far better than previous 50-18 losses.
Maybe IGG is doing something right or its our turn next for a 50k against, but that same low level has been on the top of the list for a while and he spends bigtime but his points are much less than most in top ten...

Signature
IGG ID: 194 546 514
My Databases - http://col2.forum.igg.com/topic?ctid=191116&t=1432354874
My Facebook Guild group https://www.facebook.com/groups/ArgonautsGuild/
My Guild
#10
Posted on 1/3/16 3:17:59 AM | Show thread starter's posts only

Better join other guild,,,this may hurt you but you said last thing that you loosing interest in game ,it's better join other guild

Signature